· Food & Recipes · Dessert Recipes · Make Your Own Ice Cream “Mashups”

Make Your Own Ice Cream “Mashups”

Ice Cream Mashups

If your 4th of July plans include a barbecue or cookout, chances are you’re looking for some crowd-pleasing recipes to serve your guests. Since holiday gatherings are usually all about what’s being served for dinner, it’s always nice to have something quick and simple to serve for dessert. But even for casual summertime entertaining, you still want dessert to be special, right?? These ice cream “mashups” are the perfect solution – they’re easy to make, can be prepared in advance, and have a gourmet flair that is sure to impress!

The basic idea is to dress up standard vanilla ice cream with the mix-ins of your choice. Britta, Kaitlyn and I did some experimenting and decided that 2 mix-ins was the optimal number per mashup, because it provides contrast and interest in the flavor without being overwhelming. We tried 4 different combinations for our “mashups”….

  • Chocolate + peanut butter pretzel sandwiches
  • Oatmeal cookies + blueberries
  • Honey + pistachios
  • Raspberry jam + cinnamon cereal

Ice Cream Mashups

To make a mashup, first let your vanilla ice cream warm up on your counter for a few minutes, to make it easier to work with. Then gather your mix-ins and chop them into smaller pieces, if necessary.

Ice Cream Mashups

Scoop your ice cream into a large bowl, add your mix-ins, and fold them into the ice cream. You don’t need to mix too much, just enough to incorporate the pieces.

Ice Cream Mashups

Once it’s mixed, scoop the mixture into a freezer-safe container, and place it in your freezer for at least an hour or so to allow it to harden again.

Ice Cream Mashups

Then scoop and serve whenever you’re ready!

Ice Cream Mashups

I really loved how these turned out. There’s just something about having everything mixed in and frozen together that makes it really special. In terms of flavors, I thought they were all great, but I especially liked the combination of raspberry jam and the cinnamon cereal. Cinnamon and fruit work together so well!

Ice Cream Mashups

Do yourself, and your guests, a favor this holiday and give these mashups a try. It’s a simple way to turn common vanilla ice cream into an uncommon treat.

What combinations would you like to try out in a mashup??

Ice cream mashups

Read This Next

Jill Nystul Photo

Jill Nystul (aka Jillee)

Jill Nystul is an accomplished writer and author who founded the blog One Good Thing by Jillee in 2011. With over 30 years of experience in homemaking, she has become a trusted resource for contemporary homemakers by offering practical solutions to everyday household challenges.I share creative homemaking and lifestyle solutions that make your life easier and more enjoyable!

About Jillee

Jill Nystul

Jill’s 30 years of homemaking experience, make her the trusted source for practical household solutions.

About Jillee


Food & Recipes

  • The LOreal mineral powder is terrible. It creases and blends terribly. Also, after a few hours if you touch your face, it comes off leaving a bare spot on your face. If one wants a high quality mineral powder, Mary Kay is fantastic, a larger container than bare minerals and is $18. I’m not a MK consultant either….

  • This idea is so magnificent! I can’t afford Stonecold creamery and I certainly don’t go to DQ blizzard every week. To do it at home for all of my kids, especially on a holiday, this is magnificent!!! How about blueberries, strawberries and honey and vanilla ice cream ….Yum

  • Hi there
    Love the blog and great ideas. Please, though, too many pop ups and ads that don’t go away! The Target Transformera ad is unbelievably annoying. I wish the blog content was at the top and all the ads and things were at the bottom…


  • I did this once and made an ice cream pie for a get together with it and it was a HUGE hit! Thanks for the reminder! :-)

  • Coldstone Creamery does this and it is not cheap. What a great idea to do it yourself. How about Fresh Peaches and Almonds or almond extract.

  • These remind me of the DQ blizzards. Some of our favorite combos are Oreo cookies and junior mints, releases peanut butter cups with M&’s.. The possibilities are endless.

  • >